Menu of Mayor's Restaurant in Waukesha, Wisconsin, USA

Menu Overview

Mayor's Restaurant, nestled in the heart of Waukesha, Wisconsin, offers a dining experience that feels both timeless and inviting. From the moment you step inside at 229 Wisconsin Ave, the warm, historical ambiance sets the tone for a memorable meal.

The menu at Mayor's Restaurant strikes a fine balance between classic comfort food and carefully crafted dishes that elevate everyday ingredients. Their breakfast options are particularly noteworthy. The Mayor’s Breakfast is a standout—an ample plate loaded with bacon, sausage, eggs cooked to your liking, your choice of hashbrowns or red potatoes, and fluffy pancakes or toast. This combination not only satisfies the appetite but does so with a richness that feels honest and hearty. For those seeking something lighter, the parfait with yogurt, granola, seasonal fruit, and honey offers a fresh, sweet start that contrasts nicely with the heartier fare.

The lunch sandwich offerings continue this theme of thoughtfully prepared comfort. The grilled chicken sandwich is perfectly cooked, tender and moist, accompanied by fresh lettuce, tomato, and onion on a toasted bun. The option to add wing sauce at no cost on their hand-breaded crispy chicken sandwich brings a spice and crisp texture that sets it apart. The Blackened Cajun Chicken with melted cheddar on a french roll is a delightful twist, showcasing bold flavors without overpowering the palate.

Dinner appears to be a well-curated affair here, especially based on customer favorites. The ribeye, as described by patrons, is juicy, expertly seasoned, and cooked flawlessly. Equally impressive is their fish fry featuring lightly breaded perch and cod—crisp but never greasy, paired with classic sides like roasted potato wedges, coleslaw, and broccoli cheddar soup. These dishes reflect a deep respect for fresh ingredients and traditional Wisconsin flavors. Highlighting Door County wines further strengthens Mayor’s commitment to local and regional quality.

What truly elevates Mayor’s Restaurant, beyond the food itself, is the attentive and warm service that customers consistently praise. Servers such as Jenny and Mike leave a lasting positive impression, navigating busyness with grace and genuine care. This level of hospitality complements the comfortable, clean atmosphere, making every visit feel special and well-catered.

In essence, Mayor’s Restaurant delivers a menu that excels in substance and flavor, served in an environment worthy of repeat visits. Whether it's breakfast, lunch, or dinner, the dishes feel lovingly prepared with generous portions and authentic taste. For anyone exploring dining in downtown Waukesha, Mayor’s stands as a beacon of quality, warmth, and local pride—a place where you’ll not only satisfy hunger but also enjoy the simple pleasures of great food and thoughtful service.